Why am I not losing weight although I am dieting?

It is Friday evening. I am looking forward to dancing — no, not a social event, but the Zumba dance class I religiously go to twice a week. Most of my classmates are women in their thirties and forties, making an effort to bring in some rhythm and zing into their life.

Our instructors Ridhi and Mayur, a lively wife-husband duo in their twenties, are passionate dancers and bring in enough sashaying into our work-out schedule. They ensure that everyone walks out exhilarated, after an hour of working out with several elements of fitness including cardio, muscle conditioning, and aerobics.

Any form of dance that you enjoy

To me, fitness was never about forced physical activity, but something that is an integral part of one’s life. It is hard to motivate yourself to go to an activity when you have to be pushed.

As a wellness enthusiast, I have always been holistic in my approach to life in general, embracing lifestyle choices such as yogaZumba and diet as a daily routine. Adopting such choices with a singular goal such as weight loss is usually futile and not self-sustaining. Oftentimes, people find it difficult to sustain themselves once a certain goal is reached, and usually revert back to their old habits.

On the other hand, incorporating an activity as part of the daily routine is a lot more sustainable. For example, a farmer does his daily chores in the farm, a housemaid walks to several houses, doing household chores, earning a living, and a dance teacher teaches her students dancing moves. All these people do not stop their activity once a weight goal is reached, because this is their life. For them, weight loss is not a primary goal, but a by-product of their routines.

As part of our pre-workout conversations during Zumba, my fellow dance-mate brought up a valid point. She had convinced herself to join Zumba with an eye on her waist-line, and after months of work-out, she was a tad disappointed with no noticeable change in her weight.

This is a trap most rookies walk right into. She may not have noticed that her muscles were more toned in the past few months. If exercising for fitness, my first rule is that weight should not be a metric, at least in the short term. Losing weight is certainly not indicative of a more fit body. So in her case, her fat was slowly being replaced by toned muscles.

The math and science behind weight loss

I have studied my own body weight over the years. Our body weight is essentially the sum of three broad categories — body fat masslean mass and extracellular water. In the following paragraphs, I will illustrate how each of these contributes to your body weight.

1. Weight gain due to body fat mass

Body fat mass is the fat present in the body, lean mass comprises muscles and organs like the liver, spleen, kidneys, and bones, and extracellular water is the water present external to the cells in the intercellular spaces. Overall weight gain or loss can involve any of these three categories. Let me go deeper into each of these categories.

It is common knowledge that there needs to be a balance between what we eat and how much we burn. For a person who eats more and burns less, she tends to gain weight. When energy intake in the form of food calories exceeds energy expenditure, the body stores the excess energy as fat. This could sometimes result in obesity.

This leads to the often asked question of how much energy is needed on a daily basis. Everyone needs a certain amount of energy to keep their body functioning (to breathe, keep the heart pumping, circulate blood, cell growth, and for the brain to function) at all times. This is the basal metabolic rate (BMR). In other words, it is the amount of energy you burn even if you are just sitting or sleeping all day. BMR is not a unique number but really depends on your weight, height, age, genetics, gender and muscle mass among other factors.

There are several ways to estimate one’s BMR. The World Health Organization, for example, uses something called the Schofield equation in their technical reports for estimating BMR. There are other equations as well, such as the Mifflin-St Jeor used by the US Academy of Nutrition. I have illustrated a case for a woman between 30 to 60 years of age as an example in a sequel to this article.

Someone who is very active physically needs more energy than a sedentary person. Thus, another adjustment factor should be used depending on how active the person is. The estimated total energy requirement per day (EER) is thus the addition of your BMR + the added energy requirement adjusted depending on your physical activity. It can be calculated as EER = BMR*F, where F is the adjustment factor, and depending on whether the person is sedentary, slightly active, moderately active or very active, the adjustment factor is multiplied. This is again illustrated in another article. Now that you understand BMR and EER, I have made it easier for you to estimate your BMR and EER in this calculator.

Let me summarize. Most of the energy from the food we eat is used to meet the basal metabolism. Some energy is used to sustain daily activities. Any excess usually gets deposited as fat. It is that simple.

It is imperative you understand how much food your body needs on a daily basis. Eating additional food on a long term basis can lead to obesity. Obesity in societies where food shortages were common, was considered an indication of affluence and wealth. Even today, in some rural areas of Mauritania and Western Sahara, extra body fat is admired and pubescent girls are sent to fattening huts to make them more plump and desirable for marriage by making them eat unusually large portions of food.

 As a side note, it is well known that popular film actors or boxers lose as much as 10 kg over a two month period to meet their professional objectives. They achieve that by a potent combination of diet and exercise.

Please recall the three categories of body weight that I highlighted earlier. I have already explained the body fat mass. Let me now touch upon the other two categories of body weight — lean (muscle) mass and extracellular water.


2. Weight gain due to increased muscle mass

A useful form of weight gain is the gain in muscle mass. Exercise, especially resistance training increases your muscle mass. With regular physical activity such as walking, swimming, running or strength training, one tends to reduce the body fat, but gain muscle mass simultaneously. Let us understand how this phenomenon works.

The primary building blocks for muscles are proteins. So it goes without saying that during a period of increasing muscle mass, the muscles need to be nourished and supplemented with protein-containing foods. The muscles ingest the extra proteins from the bloodstream to build new muscle fibers. This is the reason trainers advocate increased protein intake when you are doing more of strength training.

So do not panic if you don’t see a change in your weight after weeks of physical activity, especially if your primary objective is weight loss. Earning yourself a well-toned and sculpted body with a smaller waistline definitely counts as a positive change.


3. Weight gain due to increased water

Several times in your life, you may experience a bloated feeling, sometimes with swollen hands and feet. One of the reasons for that could be the extra salty food that you consumed the night before. Whenever there is excess salt in the body, the body tries to hold on to excess water to dilute the additional salt. The kidney regulates the water and ion balance in the body, and holds on to the excess water around the blood vessels — in extracellular space and in the extremities. It finally flushes it out when the balance is restored. As counterintuitive as it may sound, the body also holds on to the water when one is dehydrated as the salt water balance is again lost, and it holds on to water until the balance is restored in the form of oral rehydration solution (ORS).

While these instances illustrate the mechanism of temporary retention of water, chronic water retention in the body can occur due to kidney disease or chronic heart failure. As a piece of general wellness advice, it is best to avoid salty foods.


First of all, there are no quick and easy weight loss plans. These are well-marketed gimmicks to exploit your vulnerabilities. Many self-proclaimed diet and fitness experts have created a boom in the dieting industry by promising individuals weight loss with special diet plans or equipment. Such plans are best avoided.

Secondly, understand your bodies well. What you need is a holistic approach — which includes exercise, knowing your energy requirement according to your level of activity and working around your dietary requirement, lowering your stress levels by simple techniques like relaxation and meditation, and most important of all a plan which is sustainable.

 Last but not least, loosen up a bit. Would like to end with a quote by Gordon B. Hinckley, a religious leader — “In all of living, have much fun and laughter. Life is to be enjoyed, not just endured.”